September 21, 1973 The Spectrum, Philadelphia, Pa. (Thu)
Soundboard Master Reel > Reel > PCM > DAT (Charlie Miller Transfer)

1: Promised, Tennessee Jed, Mexicali, TLEO, L. L. Rain, Loser, BIODTL, China Cat> I Know You Rider, El Paso, Row Jimmy, Greatest> Deal, Around
2: Truckin> Eyes*> Stella Blue, Sugar Magnolia
*with Martin Fierro and Joe Ellis on horns Doug Sahm opened

September 21, 1974 Palais des Sports, Paris, France (Sat)
Soundboard Master Reel > Reel > DAT (Charlie Miller Transfer)

1: Bertha, Mexicali, Sugaree, Promised, Peggy-O, Me & My Uncle, Deal, Race Is On, Loose Lucy, El Paso, Eyes> China Doll
2: Phil & Ned> Playin> Drums> Playin
3: Row Jimmy, Big River, Ship Of Fools, Uncle John, Around, Morning Dew, Sugar Magnolia E: Casey Jones
third set with Ned Lagin

September 21, 1982 Madison Square Garden, New York, N.Y. (Tue)
Soundboard Master Cassette > DAT > CD (Charlie Miller Transfer)

1: Playin> Crazy Fingers> Me & My Uncle> Big River, West L. A., BIODTL> Loser, L. L. Rain, China Cat> I Know You Rider
2: Touch> Samson, High Time, Estimated> He's Gone> Drumz> Throwing Stones> NFA> Black Peter> Good Lovin E: U. S. Blues

September 21, 1991 Boston Garden, Boston, Ma. (Sat)
Soundboard DAT > CD (A. McCall and A. Eaglestone Transfer)

1: Bucket, TLEO, Minglewood, Peggy-O, Tom Thumb Blues, Cassidy> Deal
2: Uncle John> Saint> Eyes> Jam> Drumz> Other One> Wharf Rat> Saturday Night E: Baby Blue

September 21, 1993 Madison Square Garden, New York, N.Y. (Tue)
Soundboard DAT > Sonic Solutions > CD (Charlie Miller Transfer)

1: Bucket, Bertha> Same Thing, Peggy-O, Broken Arrow, Tennessee Jed, Music
2: H. C. Sunshine, Way To Go, Playin> Terrapin> Drumz> Last Time> Stella Blue> Sugar Magnolia E: The Weight

PhishShows on these days in History

Phish Setlists provided by Phish.net. Phish Stats from ZZYZX. Audio from Phishows.com

September 21, 1987 Nectar's, Burlington, Vt. (Mon)
Audience Cassette > DAT (Brett Stone and Paul Jones Transfer)

Set 1: The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday > Avenu Malkenu > The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday, Clod > Slave to the Traffic Light, Funky Bitch, Wilson, Dear Mrs. Reagan, Golgi Apparatus > AC/DC Bag -> Possum
Set 2: You Enjoy Myself, The Curtain With, Big Black Furry Creature from Mars, Suzy Greenberg, Alumni Blues > Letter to Jimmy Page > Alumni Blues
Set 3: Happy Birthday to You[1], Good Times Bad Times, Rocky Top[2], Sneakin' Sally through the Alley, Fee, The Divided Sky, Dog Log, The Ballad of Curtis Loew, Run Like an Antelope, Makisupa Policeman, Flat Fee, Fire, Terrapin[2], La Grange, Fluffhead
[1] "The Birthday Dub"
[2] First known Phish performance.
Notes: The listed setbreaks may be incorrect. Happy Birthday, played in a decidedly 'dub' style, was dedicated to “Spup.” This show marked the first known Phish performances of Rocky Top and Terrapin.

September 21, 1989 Pearl Street Ballroom, Northampton, Ma. (Thu)
Soundboard Cassette > DAT (Jimmy Sellers and Ben Mohr Transfer)

Set 1: Golgi Apparatus, Ya Mar, AC/DC Bag, My Sweet One, Fee, Alumni Blues > Letter to Jimmy Page > Alumni Blues, McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters > Who Do? We Do! > David Bowie
Set 2: The Divided Sky -> The Chase -> Dinner and a Movie > Bundle of Joy -> Possum, Bathtub Gin, You Enjoy Myself, If I Only Had a Brain, Run Like an Antelope
Encore: Good Times Bad Times

September 21, 1990 Somerville Theatre, Somerville, Ma. (Fri)
Audience Master Cassette (Nakamichi 300s ; John Redmond Tape ; Weave and Doomtooth Transfer)

Set 1: Reba, Paul and Silas, The Asse Festival, Dinner and a Movie, Foam, Esther, The Landlady, Mike's Song > I Am Hydrogen > Weekapaug Groove, Eliza, La Grange
Set 2: Golgi Apparatus, Magilla, Stash, Colonel Forbin's Ascent > Fly Famous Mockingbird, You Enjoy Myself[1], Highway to Hell
Encore: Whipping Post
[1] Charlie Chan and Oom Pa Pa signals; Sweet Emotion tease from Mike.
Notes: This show was a Lawn Boy release party. YEM contained Charlie Chan and Oom Pa Pa signals and a Sweet Emotion tease from Mike. Some recordings that circulate with this date are actually a compilation of performances from this show and the previous night.

September 21, 1999 Pima County Fairgrounds, Tucson, Az. (Tue)
(Digital Audience) No Source Information

Set 1: Poor Heart > Sample in a Jar, Split Open and Melt, Drowned, I Didn't Know, Back on the Train, Birds of a Feather, Theme From the Bottom, Golgi Apparatus
Set 2: Carini > Bug, Strange Design, Vultures -> Limb By Limb, Will It Go Round in Circles?, Dirt, Run Like an Antelope
Encore: Reba[1], Bold As Love
[1] No whistling.
Notes: Reba was played in an encore for the first time since March 31, 1991 (780 shows) and did not have the whistling ending.

Setlists provided by Setlist.com. Audio from Zero on Archive.org and Steve Kimock Band on Archive.org
and KVHW on Archive.org

September 21, 1996 Zero - Maritime Hall - San Francisco, Ca. (Sat)
Audience DAT (AKG C61s- on stage)

Set 1: Golden Road, The Weight, Catalina, Berm, Devil And The Trees, Crossroads
Set 2: Theme From Nancy Germany, Into the Mystic, Pits of Thunder, Tell Me All About It, Can't Keep A Good Man Down, Forever is Nowhere, Mercury Blues, E: Use Me Up
Comment: Benefit for NORML.